By Mike Kirby
When I was invited for a bone density scan at my local NHS Hospital, I joked that I was being treated like some frail, little old man.
I had been called in after breaking my wrist when I stupidly failed to properly un-clip from my pedals. Then, out running, I broke a finger and a bone in my hand slipping on mud. Two fractures in 3 months and I was a marked man. The NHS wanted to ensure I did not become a longer-term liability.
My regular readers will know I am not frail, or little. I am in my mid-sixties, and I do not regard myself as old. This year, I have ridden my bike, solo, the 1600km from Lands’ End to John O’Groats in seven days and I was a finisher of the full distance route at the 2400km Pan Celtic Race. I run regularly, but riding my bike a long way is my drug of choice. So I was stunned when the results of the scan came back. I have Osteoporosis
I immediately had many questions. Can Osteoporosis be reversed or slowed and what do I need to do? This tipped me into a world of detailed medical studies, and peer reviewed papers, determined to learn all I could. One thing quickly became clear, a lot of road riding, to the exclusion of other exercise is not good for your bones.
Osteoporosis generally effects the elderly. Bone fragility leads to a greater incidence of frailty, falls and fractures. The prognosis for older people (65 plus) with hip or femur fractures is shockingly poor. Between 15 and 30% will be dead within a year according to Peter Attia in his book Outlive. Fractures and the rapid functional decline that results, shorten lifespans.
My voyage of discovery started to yield some disturbing details. A systematic review by Olmedillas and others in BMC Medicine, accepts that cycling is highly beneficial in many respects. But there are no corresponding improvements in bone density resulting from riding a bike. Low bone density was observed in road cyclists who train regularly. It is, however, less marked in mountain bikers, and in those who combine cycling with other sports.
Nagle and others writing in Sports Health, found that bone mass was the same as, or slightly lower in cyclists than in the sedentary population. It was also noted that four separate studies showed bone mass to be lower in cyclists than in other active people, including runners. Crucially, one study found that the ‘level of practice’ and/or the number of years of training is a causal factor in increasing risk of low bone mass.
A study by R.Scott-Rector and others in a journal called Metabolism, compared cyclists with runners: None weight bearing athletes with those who practiced weight bearing sport.
The cyclists had significantly lower bone mineral density compared with the runners, despite having similar age, weight, body mass index, and composition. Sixty-three percent of the bike riders had osteopenia (an ‘early stage’ loss of bone density) of the spine or hip, compared with nineteen percent of runners. Cyclists were 7 times more likely to have osteopenia of the spine than runners.
But there is good news too. Wilks et al, writing in Medicine and Science of Sports and Exercise found that combining cycling and running counteracts the detrimental effect of cycling alone. Wilks and co also found greater bone mass in sprint cyclists than in long distance riders, probably explained by the fact that weight/resistance training was found to have significant positive influences on bone mass.
My concern is this: In recent years there has been an explosion in riding longer distances. Cycling weekly reported that in 2022, that there was a 46% increase in the number of people logging 100 mile rides on Strava compared to the previous year. The Covid-19 cycling boom undoubtedly contributed. There are dozens of ‘Ultra Distance’ rides and races now. The training required to ride long means ‘level of practice’ has grown at least in terms of duration. As populations age, so the number of years older riders like me have spent in the saddle is increasing, potentially multiplying the numbers that will discover Osteoporosis as I did.
We are all trailing indicators of our lifelong habits and our genes. I eat a very good diet, but both my parents were frail in their final years. Even younger and middle-aged bike riders may be laying the ground for future bone health issues. Offsetting health problems by addressing them earlier, increases the chances of avoiding or at least, delaying them. Osteoporosis is important for all cyclists of all ages.
I needed to make some changes. I have always done a little running, sometimes more than just a little. But, preparing for my longer cycling challenges has naturally meant that long distance cycling has been my dominant form of exercise. I have no intention of stopping any time soon, but I do need to adjust. Peter Attia describes exercise as the very best drug to take to ensure you live well for much longer. I will certainly run more. I have always loved to do this anyway, so it is not a chore. I may spend more time in the gym and I will mix all this with a healthy dose of riding my bike, still craving the world of endless possibilities that waits for us as we head up the road.
As to whether Osteoporosis is reversible, the scientific community seems split. There is no ‘cure’, that is certain, but with a nutrient dense diet, supplemented with Vitamin D and Calcium in particular, plus load bearing exercise like running and regular resistance training, further bone mineral density decline can be prevented. That is my goal.
Follow Mike Kirby, the Cycle Scribe, on Substack – @thecyclescribe


